Play It Again Sports in Fishers, IN, offers a wide range of new and used sporting goods at reasonable prices. The store is well-stocked with equipment for various sports, including disc golf, soccer, and golf. The staff is knowledgeable and eager to assist, creating a friendly and helpful environment for both newcomers and regulars. This location is especially supportive of families and athletes on a budget, making it a popular choice for local sports enthusiasts.
However, despite the overall positive reception, some customers have found the prices for used gear to be high. There have also been occasional issues with inventory accuracy and customer service inconsistency. These factors slightly tarnish an otherwise excellent reputation.
Pros:
- Wide range of new and used sporting goods
- Reasonable prices
- Friendly and knowledgeable staff
- Helpful and eager assistants
- Great for families and budget-conscious shoppers
- Well-stocked with various sports equipment
- Both new and used items available
- Good environment for shopping
- Highly rated by many customers
- Supports local community
Cons:
- Occasional high prices for used gear
- Inventory accuracy issues
- Customer service inconsistency
Description
Sporting goods chain that buys, sells & trades a wide variety of equipment, both new & secondhand.
Location / Contact
- Address: 11681 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46037, United States
- Phone:+1 317-288-4632
- Website:playitagainsportsfishers.com
Rating Stats
Reviews (90)
Frequently Asked Questions
Except the peak hours, this place remains quite free or moderately crowded.
This business has a rating of 4.4-star.
This business has 90 reviews.
The address is: 11681 Olio Rd, Fishers, IN 46037, United States .
The contact number is +1 317-288-4632
This service is listed under Sporting Goods Store .
Add a Review
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
People Also Viewed
Matt Bell
2 years ago
Thank you for the 5 stars! We thank you for your business!
Andy Patterson
2 years ago
Tami Baker
2 years ago
TamiWe strive to have excellent customer service for every customer that visits our stores. Please share with me what we did to get the 3 stars! [email protected] sell 50-50 new and used products and will match any competitors new item price online, or locally!
Craig White
2 years ago
Great people
Debra Pierce
2 years ago
Helpful. Bought a piece of exercise equipment and they will deliver and set up in our home.
Joe Eaton
2 years ago
Great sporting goods store selling used and new equipment. Staff there was great to work with. Probably the best play it agai. store I have seen.
Zachary Alexander Curtis
2 years ago
I was recommended to Play it Again Sports by my Behavioral Therapist recommended you guys Very wonderful experience and Customer Service the young man that helped us was honest & helpful and polite he goes to our Church and the guys that delivered the Treadmill showed up on time and stayed until they were done and showed us how to use the Treadmill I've had the Treadmill for a few weeks now and it is a great treadmill definitely would recommend your store to my friends and family I give this store a excellent review very good quality and signed up for the warranty 100% awesome Customer Service
XposedbyTruth
2 years ago
I am a local business owner in the Fishers area. I am also African American. A frequent customer at Vs barbershop (I highly recommend by the way) I walked in and was not greeted, I was stared at and looked up and down. I wanted by a new elliptical, and bench and weights for my son. I seen Everything I was looking for. No one spoke to me at all. Each Caucasian male and female that walked in received a warm greeting, a smile and was asked how they could be helped! Needles to say I kept my AMEX in my hoodie pocket( yes hoodie) I was in gym clothes....does that really matter? I will purchase elsewhere. Hopefully the owner has cameras and can review and train his staff that all customers are valued no matter their skin color. I and my wife are certainly going to share our experience with our very large number of valued clients who always ask us and our staff for recommendations. If you are African American I would encourage you to shop elsewhere. God Bless and I hope this review helps someone else to not experience the treatment or behavior that we’ll never did nor certainly doesn’t belong to day! VERY DISAPPOINTED and DO NOT RECOMMEND!
John Aoun
2 years ago
Our family's automatic 1st stop if we need any sports equipment. Selection is usually good and staff is always helpful.Definitely makes having multiple kiddos involved in multiple sports more affordable.
Erik Baugh
3 years ago
Thanks Visiting our store and for the Five Stars!