My Time Fitness is a 24/7 gym located at 1501 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle, OH. Members appreciate its cleanliness, quiet environment, and well-maintained facilities. The gym provides a high standard for all equipment and has a friendly and outgoing owner, making it a unique experience compared to larger chain gyms.
Despite its many strengths, My Time Fitness faces criticism for only having one co-ed bathroom and shower, limited staff presence, and occasional equipment issues during peak hours. It may get busy from 5-9 PM, affecting availability for workouts.
Pros:
- Open 24/7
- Clean and well-maintained
- Friendly and outgoing owner
- High standards of equipment
- Quiet environment
- Good amount of natural light
- Separate room for freestyle workouts
- Classy atmosphere
- Positive long-term member reviews
Cons:
- One co-ed bathroom and shower
- Limited staff presence
- Busy during peak hours (5-9 PM)
Location / Contact
- Address: 2302, 1501 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle, OH 45344, United States
- Phone:+1 937-849-9100
- Email:[email protected]
- Website:mytimefitnessllc.com
Rating Stats
Reviews (10)
Frequently Asked Questions
Except the peak hours, this place remains quite free or moderately crowded.
This business has a rating of 4.4-star.
This business has 10 reviews.
The address is: 2302, 1501 S Dayton-Lakeview Rd, New Carlisle, OH 45344, United States .
The contact number is +1 937-849-9100
This service is listed under Gym .
Add a Review
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *









Nick Lutz
1 year ago
Excellent gym! Classy Owner! Nothing like the other chain gyms I’ve been a member of.
James Smith
2 years ago
Excellent workout experience
Melissa Shampton
2 years ago
I have been a member for 6 yrs. Love it! Highly recommend this facility.
Amanda Gomez
2 years ago
Every time I stop by during 'business hours' nobody is there. Sadly.
Marvin McClure
2 years ago
I have been going there for Several years now. There is 2 bathrooms and I might have waited twice to use. Its always clean and in working order. There is a lot of moving parts not to mention the people factor. Sometimes things do break,But Michelle is always on it. Sometimes she is at the mercy of the technician's. I love going there.
Otis B
2 years ago
Everything you need. Always clean and quiet with a nice class of people. Owner has always been outgoing and friendly while maintaining a high standard for the gym. Tons of ambient light with a separate room for more freestyle workouts.
Cbherdman
5 years ago
I went with a friend to check it out. A small but nice place. They do though have a serious set back. ONE bathroom, co-ed. The ONE shower is also located in the co-ed bathroom. So, if you got to go to the bathroom and someone is showering well you probably will have to go to the Speedway. That's a serious issue for me. They need to fix that. That's a poor design. I won't be getting my membership. My friend said if I go at certain times that's not an issue. Really? It should have never been designed that way.
Cindy Conley
6 years ago
There's NEVER staff there if you need to know how to use a piece of equipment so make sure to ask all your questions when you sign up for membership. Other than that, it's clean, well maintained and open 24/7
Sarah Roderick
7 years ago
Nothing up dated, they charge so much a month and but things are missing when I go to look for them. The small place get's busy on hours from 5-9pm and it's hard to find a place to work out. Then there some people that gossip about others working out. I heard them over and over poking fun of a lot of people in there.
Panda (PandaMatic)
7 years ago
Great 24 hour gym. Machines need a bit of maintenance.