Play It Again Sports, located at 1705 S 1st Ave D, Iowa City, IA, offers an extensive range of new and used sporting goods. They cater to athletes of all ages and sports, ensuring affordability and high-quality items. The store provides excellent customer service with knowledgeable and helpful staff, making it easy for customers to find what they need.

However, some customers have expressed dissatisfaction with the prices received when selling used equipment back to the store. Despite this, Play It Again Sports remains a popular choice for many due to its diverse selection and competitive pricing.

Pros:

  • Great selection of new and used sporting equipment
  • Knowledgeable and helpful staff
  • Competitive pricing
  • High-quality items
  • Organized and clean store
  • New items arrive regularly
  • Staff not pushy with sales
  • Ideal for families with kids in sports
  • Positive customer service experiences

Cons:

  • Low payouts for selling used equipment
  • Limited options for selling back
  • Some dissatisfaction with trade-in values

Description

Sporting goods chain that buys, sells & trades a wide variety of equipment, both new & secondhand.

Location / Contact

Rating Stats

4.5

out of 5.0

1 reviews
5.0
1 reviews
4.0
8 reviews
3.0
0 reviews
2.0
0 reviews
1.0

Reviews (10)

author-img

DO NOT SELL YOUR USED EQUIPMENT HERE! The policy is apparently to find the cheapest look alije being advertised on ebay, then claim they'll sell it for half of that price, so they can only pay you a third of what "they'd" sell it for. For example, a 200$ to 300$ pair of ice skates, would be sold for 80$, so they could only buy them for 20$. If that's true, they aren't just ripping off customers, they're ripping themselves off too. Even if you can show them the exact item on ebay for a more reasonable price, "their hands are tied." What a joke.

author-img

Evan I believe his name was . . . Super amazing to work with on our baseball gloves. Tightened one and strung up the other

author-img

Super helpful. Needed a tennis racket and got a great used one for $20. Out in 5 min.

author-img

Great local store for used and new items!

author-img

The best used sporting equipment store I've ever been in! Excellent selection of new and used.

author-img

The selection is great, the employees are so wonderful and the prices and savings blow your mind!!!! I was there grabbing baseball equipment and I had no idea what I was looking for in a mitt. The staff was extremely knowledgeable, helpful and patient! They have something for just about every sport in there. You WONT find better prices either!!! I can promise you that what we bought would have cost $400 at Scheels which is the main other option in the area and we only spent $36 at Play-it-Again!!!! 🤯 And we got some nice used equipment too!!! It was in next to new shape!! Just took it all home and shined it up and conditioned the leather and you couldn't even tell it wasn't new! They do have some new items there as well but even those are a fraction of the price of new at Scheels! Wish I found out about this place YEARS ago!!! We will DEFINITELY be visiting again!

author-img

If you have kids in sports this is the first place you should look for any kind of sporting equipment they may need. They have a wide variety of sporting equipment for all ages. I have never had an issue with quality- it seems like they do a great job of choosing the best quality stuff to put in their store. Staff is incredibly knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful!

author-img

Wonderful place--lots of sporting equipment, know-how, and reasonably priced. Chris and all his guys are easy to work with and don't use the high pressure tactics to "get the sale" that many other places use. We purchased our first treadmill from them in 2011 and our second in 2023.

author-img

Well taken care of. Neat and orderly. Excellent customer service. Great selection. Visited 3 weeks later had a lot of new seasonal items. The reason I go there at least once a month.

author-img

Sold 2 basketball shoes worth around $60 and fairly new football cleats worth below $70, and got $25 out of all those 3 shoes combined. Smh, do better with your deals.

No reviews yet

Frequently Asked Questions

Except the peak hours, this place remains quite free or moderately crowded.

This business has a rating of 4.5-star.

This business has 10 reviews.

The address is: 1705 S 1st Ave D, Iowa City, IA 52240, United States .

The contact number is +1 319-354-4777

This service is listed under Sporting Goods Store .

Add a Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this business! *
Add Photos